EB-2-NIW Approved for an AI-Driven Materials Science Researcher After Successful RFE Response

EB-2-NIW Approved for an AI-Driven Materials Science Researcher After Successful RFE Response

EB-2-NIW Approved for an AI-Driven Materials Science Researcher After Successful RFE Response

Specialty Area: 🤖 Advanced Engineering Materials & Artificial Intelligence

Manifest Attorney: Carmiann Cespedes

This case was a particularly meaningful victory for Manifest Law. The applicant came to us after receiving an RFE on their self-filed EB2-NIW petition, facing serious pushback from USCIS on all three prongs of the Matter of Dhanasar framework. The RFE questioned the applicant’s eligibility under the advanced degree category, the national importance of their proposed endeavor, and whether it would be beneficial to the United States to waive the labor certification requirement.

How Manifest Made It Happen

How Manifest Made It Happen

Upon review, we immediately recognized that the original filing had incorrectly framed the petition under the advanced degree category, when in fact the strongest argument was under the exceptional ability category. Manifest recalibrated the response to make this distinction clear and provided detailed, organized evidence proving the petitioner met the criteria.

We showcased the applicant’s groundbreaking research in the intersection of artificial intelligence and advanced materials science, emphasizing its alignment with national priorities like the Materials Genome Initiative and the White House’s Critical and Emerging Technologies List. Our response detailed how the applicant’s work—involving AI-driven materials discovery and optimization—contributes directly to sectors such as defense, healthcare, sustainable manufacturing, and energy security. We connected the scientific merit of the research to real-world national interests, demonstrating both urgency and relevance.

Finally, we made a compelling argument that waiving the labor certification would benefit the United States, not only because of the applicant’s unique qualifications and strategic vision, but also because the nature of their work is too critical to delay through traditional labor certification processes. Our response balanced technical detail with policy relevance, making it clear thatour client’s ongoing contributions are aligned with U.S. innovation and security goals.

The result: USCIS approved the petition with no additional questions

The result: USCIS approved the petition with no additional questions

This case is a powerful example of how a well-executed RFE response—based on a deep understanding of both immigration law and the underlying science—can turn a near-denial into a success story.

If you’ve received an RFE or been told your case isn’t viable, let Manifest Law take a second look. We’re here to turn possibilities into approvals.

Wondering if you are eligible for a visa?

Wondering if you are eligible for a visa?

Wondering if you are eligible for a visa?

Request a consultation with Manifest team to find out.

Request a consultation with Manifest team to find out.

Request a consultation with Manifest team to find out.

Attorney Advertising. This website is intended for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice and is no substitute for consulting a licensed attorney. Only an attorney can provide you with legal advice, and only after considering your specific facts and circumstances. You should not act on any information on this website without first seeking the advice of an attorney. Manifest Law is an association of lawyers and legal entities that have agreed to do business under a common name, which includes Manifest Legal Services LLC and Manifest Law, PLLC. The use of the name “Manifest Law” does not imply that all lawyers or legal entities within the Manifest Law family are part of a single partnership or that they are responsible for the acts or omissions of each other.  Any specific attorney-client engagement, the scope of any such attorney-client relationship, and the legal responsibility for any such engagement will be set forth in the retainer agreement entered into between the client and the relevant Manifest Law attorney(s). All legal services are conducted by licensed immigration professionals. Manifest Legal is an Arizona ABS company. This website is regulated by the Arizona Rules of Professional Conduct

2025 Manifest Copyright. All Rights Reserved.

Attorney Advertising. This website is intended for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice and is no substitute for consulting a licensed attorney. Only an attorney can provide you with legal advice, and only after considering your specific facts and circumstances. You should not act on any information on this website without first seeking the advice of an attorney. Manifest Law is an association of lawyers and legal entities that have agreed to do business under a common name, which includes Manifest Legal Services LLC and Manifest Law, PLLC. The use of the name “Manifest Law” does not imply that all lawyers or legal entities within the Manifest Law family are part of a single partnership or that they are responsible for the acts or omissions of each other.  Any specific attorney-client engagement, the scope of any such attorney-client relationship, and the legal responsibility for any such engagement will be set forth in the retainer agreement entered into between the client and the relevant Manifest Law attorney(s). All legal services are conducted by licensed immigration professionals. Manifest Legal is an Arizona ABS company. This website is regulated by the Arizona Rules of Professional Conduct

2025 Manifest Copyright. All Rights Reserved.

Attorney Advertising. This website is intended for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice and is no substitute for consulting a licensed attorney. Only an attorney can provide you with legal advice, and only after considering your specific facts and circumstances. You should not act on any information on this website without first seeking the advice of an attorney. Manifest Law is an association of lawyers and legal entities that have agreed to do business under a common name, which includes Manifest Legal Services LLC and Manifest Law, PLLC. The use of the name “Manifest Law” does not imply that all lawyers or legal entities within the Manifest Law family are part of a single partnership or that they are responsible for the acts or omissions of each other.  Any specific attorney-client engagement, the scope of any such attorney-client relationship, and the legal responsibility for any such engagement will be set forth in the retainer agreement entered into between the client and the relevant Manifest Law attorney(s). All legal services are conducted by licensed immigration professionals. Manifest Legal is an Arizona ABS company. This website is regulated by the Arizona Rules of Professional Conduct

2025 Manifest Copyright. All Rights Reserved.

Attorney Advertising. This website is intended for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice and is no substitute for consulting a licensed attorney. Only an attorney can provide you with legal advice, and only after considering your specific facts and circumstances. You should not act on any information on this website without first seeking the advice of an attorney. Manifest Law is an association of lawyers and legal entities that have agreed to do business under a common name, which includes Manifest Legal Services LLC and Manifest Law, PLLC. The use of the name “Manifest Law” does not imply that all lawyers or legal entities within the Manifest Law family are part of a single partnership or that they are responsible for the acts or omissions of each other.  Any specific attorney-client engagement, the scope of any such attorney-client relationship, and the legal responsibility for any such engagement will be set forth in the retainer agreement entered into between the client and the relevant Manifest Law attorney(s). All legal services are conducted by licensed immigration professionals. Manifest Legal is an Arizona ABS company. This website is regulated by the Arizona Rules of Professional Conduct

2025 Manifest Copyright. All Rights Reserved.